Local Food Gifts from the Chattanooga Area
Looking for a Chattanooga food gift that feels truly local? A jar of small-batch nut butter from Cleo Nut Butter Co, ground and blended in small batches in Tennessee, is an easy one to match to the person you have in mind. Here is how to choose a jar, how to get it there in time, and what the person you give it to should know.
The short answer: A jar of small-batch nut butter from Cleo Nut Butter Co is a local food gift you can match to the person: a familiar honey-sweetened peanut butter, a one-ingredient cashew butter, a maple vanilla cashew butter, or a naturally caffeine-free carob spread. The jars are ground and blended in small batches in Tennessee, with ingredient lists short enough to read out loud, no added oils, and no preservatives. You can pick up in Chattanooga, Cleveland, or Ooltewah, arrange local delivery in the Cleveland, Ooltewah, and McDonald areas, or ship within Tennessee. The shop does not ship out of state yet.

Why a jar of small-batch nut butter works as a local gift
A good food gift says something about the person and something about the place. A jar of nut butter does both. You can pick a flavor that suits the person, a classic peanut butter for one friend and a maple vanilla cashew butter for another, and you are giving something made close to home.
Every Cleo Nut Butter Co jar has an ingredient list short enough to read out loud, with no added oils, no palm oil and no preservatives. The person you give it to can turn the jar over and see exactly what is in it. If you are curious how that compares with what is on the grocery shelf, here is how small-batch and grocery store nut butter compare.
A jar also fits the moments when you want to bring something along: a hostess gift for a dinner, a holiday gift for a neighbor or coworker, or a thank-you for someone who helped you out. It does not need to be eaten that night, and it does not take up room in anyone's freezer.
Want to know what to look for before you choose? Our free nut butter buying guide is a one-page label checklist that works on any jar, ours included.
Which jar to give
Cleo Nut Butter Co makes six jars from three kinds of nut. Here is a quick way to match one to the person.
A familiar peanut butter gift
For someone who already loves peanut butter, Honey Glazed Roasted Peanut Butter is the easy pick: dry roasted peanuts and wildflower honey, and that is all ($13.99, 16 oz). For someone who would enjoy a toastier, less familiar flavor, Toasty Carob Peanut Butter adds organic Australian carob powder and organic cane sugar, and it is naturally caffeine-free ($15.99, 16 oz). See all of our small-batch peanut butter.
Cashew butter, unsweetened or gently sweet
Pure Cashew Butter is one ingredient, dry roasted cashews, and it is the only unsweetened jar in the shop. It suits someone who likes to cook or add their own toppings ($15.99, 16 oz). Maple Vanilla Cashew Butter adds Vermont maple sugar and Madagascar ground vanilla bean powder for someone with a sweet tooth ($17.99, 16 oz). Toasty Carob Cashew Butter is the mellow, naturally caffeine-free carob option ($17.99, 16 oz). If you are wondering why cashew butter costs more than peanut butter, our guide on how to choose cashew butter explains it. See all of our small-batch cashew butter.
A hazelnut and carob spread
Hazelnut Carob Spread is roasted hazelnuts, organic Australian carob powder, organic cane sugar and sunflower lecithin. It is smooth, toasty and gently sweet, and like all of our carob jars it is naturally caffeine-free. It is also the only 12 oz jar ($19.99). Carob is not chocolate. It has a flavor all its own, so if the person has never tried it, here is what carob tastes like. See our hazelnut spread with carob.
Can't decide? You can order one jar or several. See all six in the Cleo Nut Butter Co shop.
How to get it there in time
This is the part that matters most for a gift. Most Cleo Nut Butter Co jars are made to order in small batches in Tennessee, and our most popular flavors are sometimes made in small batches ahead. That makes a jar a thoughtful local gift rather than a last-minute one, so plan around preparation time, not only the drive or the mail.
Pickup in Chattanooga, Cleveland, or Ooltewah
Local pickup is free, with no minimum order. Choose Pickup at checkout, and we will email you a time and place. Pickup is usually ready in 5 or more days. Here is how nut butter pickup in Chattanooga works.
Picking up in Cleveland or Ooltewah? Checkout lists the Chattanooga pickup location on every pickup order, and we arrange your actual pickup by email, as explained on our page about nut butter pickup in Cleveland and Ooltewah.
Local delivery in Cleveland, Ooltewah, and McDonald
Local delivery is free on orders of $50 or more in the Cleveland, Ooltewah and McDonald areas (ZIP codes 37311, 37312, 37323, 37363, 37341, 37421 and 37353). Choose Local delivery at checkout, and we will email you to schedule a time.
Shipping within Tennessee
We ship to addresses in Tennessee by USPS for $6.99, or free on Tennessee orders of $50 or more. Please allow 7 to 10 business days of preparation before the order ships, then usually 5 to 7 business days in transit. Holidays can add a few days, and delivery estimates are not guaranteed.
Sending the jar straight to the person? At checkout, enter their name and Tennessee address as the delivery address.
If the recipient lives outside Tennessee
We do not ship out of state yet, and there is no way around that for now. If the person you have in mind lives outside Tennessee, join the nationwide shipping waitlist and we will email you when shipping opens in their state.
| Where | Cost | Timing | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pickup | Chattanooga, Cleveland or Ooltewah, by arrangement | Free, no minimum | Usually ready in 5 or more days |
| Local delivery | Cleveland, Ooltewah and McDonald areas | Free on orders of $50 or more | Scheduled by email |
| Shipping | Tennessee addresses only | $6.99, or free on Tennessee orders of $50 or more | 7 to 10 business days of preparation, then usually 5 to 7 business days by USPS |
Outside Tennessee? Join the nationwide shipping waitlist.
What the recipient should know
A few notes are worth passing along with the jar:
- Oil on top is normal. Cleo Nut Butter Co jars have no added oils, so the nut's own oil can rise, especially when it is warm. Stir it back in before using. Here is why oil separates in natural nut butter.
- Storage: there are no preservatives. Unopened, keep the jar in a cool, dark place. After opening, refrigerate it, and enjoy it while it is fresh. Storing the jar upside down or in the fridge helps slow separation.
- Allergens: every jar contains peanuts or tree nuts, and our kitchen handles both. Peanuts are kept on separate equipment from tree nuts. Please check the "Contains" line on each jar before you give it.
- If a jar arrives damaged: email hello@cleonutbutter.com within 7 days of delivery and we will make it right, as described in our FAQ.
Questions
What is a good local food gift from the Chattanooga area?
A jar of small-batch nut butter from Cleo Nut Butter Co is a local food gift you can match to the person: a familiar honey-sweetened peanut butter, a one-ingredient cashew butter, a maple vanilla cashew butter, or a naturally caffeine-free carob spread. The jars are ground and blended in small batches in Tennessee, with ingredient lists short enough to read out loud, no added oils, and no preservatives. You can pick up in Chattanooga, Cleveland, or Ooltewah, arrange local delivery in the Cleveland, Ooltewah, and McDonald areas, or ship within Tennessee. The shop does not ship out of state yet.
Can I pick up a nut butter gift in Cleveland, Ooltewah, or Chattanooga?
Yes. Local pickup is free, with no minimum order, and is arranged after you check out. Pickup is usually ready in 5 or more days, and Cleo Nut Butter Co will email you a time and place. Choose Pickup at checkout. If you are picking up in Cleveland or Ooltewah, checkout may still list the Chattanooga pickup location; that is only the label on the order, and the actual pickup is arranged by email. See the Chattanooga pickup page or the Cleveland and Ooltewah pickup page for the details.
Do you ship nut butter gifts outside Tennessee?
Not yet. Cleo Nut Butter Co ships to addresses in Tennessee only, by USPS, for $6.99, or free on Tennessee orders of $50 or more. Please allow 7 to 10 business days for preparation before the order ships, then usually 5 to 7 business days in transit. If the recipient lives outside Tennessee, join the nationwide shipping waitlist and you will get an email when shipping opens in your state.
How far in advance should I order a made-to-order nut butter gift?
Plan around prep time, not only carrier transit. Most Cleo Nut Butter Co jars are made to order in small batches in Tennessee, and our most popular flavors are sometimes made in small batches ahead. For a shipped gift, allow 7 to 10 business days of preparation before the order ships, then usually 5 to 7 business days for USPS delivery within Tennessee. Local pickup is usually ready in 5 or more days. Holidays can add a few days, and delivery estimates are not guaranteed.
Do you sell gift sets or gift wrap?
Not at this time. Cleo Nut Butter Co sells six jars, and you can order one jar or several. The shop does not currently offer a pre-packed gift set, gift wrap, or a gift card. If you are picking the jars up locally, you can wrap them yourself. Tennessee orders of $50 or more ship free, and orders of $50 or more in the Cleveland, Ooltewah and McDonald areas deliver free.
Will the jar have oil on top, and is that all right as a gift?
A layer of oil on top is normal, especially when it is warm. Cleo Nut Butter Co jars have no added oils and no preservatives, so the nut's own oil can rise. Stir it back in before using. Keep the jar in a cool, dark place, refrigerate it after opening, and enjoy it while it is fresh. You may want to mention the oil to the person you are giving it to, so they know to stir. For a fuller explanation, see why oil separates in natural nut butter.