Cashew Butter Guide: How to Choose

The short answer: To choose a good cashew butter, read the label before the price. Cashews should be the first ingredient, the list should be short enough to read out loud, and any added oil or sweetener should be one you picked on purpose. Then compare price per ounce, not price per jar, because cashew butter costs more for real reasons, and a very cheap jar usually has something else doing the work.

Roasted cashews in a small bowl.

Cashew butter is mellow, creamy and gently sweet on its own. It is also one of the more expensive spreads on the shelf, which makes it worth knowing what you are paying for. This guide from Cleo Nut Butter Co covers how to read a cashew butter label, why the price is higher than peanut butter, how cashew butter compares with peanut butter, how to use it, and how to store it so every spoonful tastes the way it should.

How to choose cashew butter: a label-first method

The front of a jar tells you the flavor. The back tells you what you are buying. These five checks take about a minute, and they work on any jar, ours included.

  1. Check the first ingredient. Ingredients are listed by weight, from most to least. If the front says cashew butter, cashews should come first. If an oil, a sweetener or a different nut comes before them, the jar is mostly something else.
  2. Look for added oils. Some cashew butters add palm oil or another vegetable oil to keep the jar smooth and stir free on the shelf. That is a choice, not a flaw, but it makes a different product, and the label tells you which one you are holding. A cashew butter with no added oil will separate a little in the jar, and that is normal.
  3. Name the sweetener, if there is one. Plain cashew butter does not need a sweetener, because cashews are naturally mild and a little sweet. Flavored jars often add sugar, maple, honey or something else. Check what it is, how many sweeteners are listed, and where they fall on the list.
  4. Watch for blends. Some cashew spreads are blended with other nuts or seeds that cost less. If the label lists peanuts, almonds or sunflower seeds alongside cashews, it is a blend. A blend can taste great, but it is a different product at a different price, and it should not be compared with a pure cashew butter jar for jar.
  5. Read the "Contains" line. Cashews are tree nuts. The allergen statement tells you what the jar contains, and many labels also say what else is handled in the kitchen where it was made. Read it every time, even on a brand you know.

Roasted or raw? Labels often say whether the cashews are roasted or raw. Roasted cashews give a deeper, toastier flavor, while raw cashews make a paler, milder butter. Neither is better. It comes down to the taste you want, and the label should tell you which one is in the jar.

Smooth or crunchy? Most cashew butter is smooth, because cashews are soft and creamy to begin with. If a jar says crunchy or chunky, expect pieces of cashew stirred through.

If you can read the whole list out loud and say why each ingredient is there, you know what you are buying. An unfamiliar ingredient is not automatically bad, but you should know why it is in the jar.

Why does cashew butter cost more?

Cashew butter costs more than peanut butter mostly because cashews cost more, long before anyone turns them into a spread. Three things drive the price.

How a cashew grows

A peanut grows underground, two or three to a pod, and comes out of the ground by machine. A cashew grows one nut at a time, hanging below a fruit called the cashew apple. Each cashew apple carries a single nut, so there is far less to harvest from each tree than there is from a field of peanuts.

The shell

The cashew shell holds a caustic oil that can burn the skin. Before a cashew can be shelled, it has to be roasted, boiled or steamed, and much of the shelling is still done by hand. FoodPrint points to the labor and time it takes to shell cashews by hand as a main reason they cost more than other nuts. Every broken kernel is also worth less than a whole one, so care at every step matters.

The journey

Most cashews travel a long way before they reach a jar. Côte d'Ivoire (Ivory Coast) became the world's top cashew exporter in 2015, and most of its crop is exported raw to Vietnam or India for processing, according to Oxford Business Group. Vietnam leads the world in cashew processing capacity, but it grows only a small share of the raw nuts it needs and imports most of the rest, mainly from Africa and Cambodia, as reported by Viet Nam News. Growing, shelling, shipping and shipping again all show up in the price of the nut.

Use price as a shopping cue

Because the cashews are the costly part, the price of a pure cashew butter mostly reflects the price of the nut. That makes price a useful clue when you shop:

  • Compare price per ounce. Jar sizes vary, so the price per jar can be misleading. Most shelf tags show the price per ounce. Use it.
  • Treat a very low price as a question. If a cashew butter costs far less than the rest of the shelf, flip it over. A cheaper oil, a filler nut or extra sugar may be carrying part of the jar. The label will tell you.
  • Do not treat a high price as proof. A higher price does not guarantee a better jar on its own. The ingredient list is still the test.

Weighing a small-batch jar against a grocery store one? Here is how small-batch and grocery store nut butter compare.

Take the checklist shopping

Our free Simple-Ingredient Nut Butter Buying Guide turns these checks into a one-page checklist, with a worksheet for comparing two jars side by side. It is a free PDF, delivered to your inbox.

Get the free nut butter buying guide

Cashew butter vs. peanut butter

Both are spreads made from ground nuts, and both belong in a good pantry. Here is how they differ:

  • Taste: Cashew butter is mellow, creamy and gently sweet. Peanut butter is bolder and more roasted.
  • Texture: Cashew butter tends to be soft and smooth enough to drizzle. Peanut butter is usually thicker.
  • Where they come from: Peanuts are legumes that grow underground. Cashews are tree nuts that grow on the cashew tree.
  • Allergen labeling: Peanuts and tree nuts are listed separately on food labels, so check the "Contains" line on each jar.
  • Price: Cashew butter usually costs more, for the reasons above.

Which one is better comes down to how you plan to use it. Peanut butter shines in a classic sandwich and anywhere you want a bold roasted flavor. Cashew butter is the one to reach for when you want creaminess without a strong nut taste.

Cashew Butter vs Almond Butter

Cashew butter and almond butter are both made from tree nuts, and both work in many of the same places. The differences show up in texture, taste and how you use them.

  • Texture: Cashew butter is usually soft and creamy, often smooth enough to drizzle. Almond butter tends to be thicker, and some jars have a slightly grainy feel.
  • Taste: Cashew butter is mild and gently sweet. Almond butter has a stronger, nuttier flavor, with a toasty edge when the almonds are roasted.
  • Common uses: Both are good on toast, apple slices and oatmeal, and both blend easily into smoothies. Cashew butter is a natural fit for creamy sauces, curries and dressings, where its mild flavor stays in the background. Almond butter suits recipes where you want the nut flavor to come through.

If you want the creamiest, mildest option, start with cashew butter. See our small-batch cashew butters.

How to use cashew butter

Cashew butter's mild flavor makes it easy to use in both sweet and savory food. A few favorites:

  • Spread on crisp apple slices or sliced banana.
  • Blended into a morning smoothie.
  • Stirred into a creamy curry or a noodle sauce.
  • Whisked with lemon juice, a little warm water and a pinch of salt for a quick dressing.
  • Spread on pancakes and waffles, or stirred into warm oatmeal.
  • Rolled up in a warm crepe or spread on rice cakes.
  • Dolloped onto yogurt with fresh berries.
  • Straight from the spoon.

In savory cooking, a spoonful of cashew butter adds body and creaminess to a sauce without taking over the flavor. In sweet food, it plays well with fruit, maple and vanilla.

How to store cashew butter

Cleo Nut Butter Co cashew butters have no preservatives, so a little care keeps every jar tasting its best:

  • Unopened: Keep the jar in a cool, dark place.
  • Opened: Refrigerate after opening, and enjoy it while it is fresh.
  • Oil on top: Natural oil separation is normal. Stir the whole jar, all the way to the bottom, until the oil is mixed back in. Storing the jar upside down can help slow separation. Here is why oil separates in natural nut butter.

Our cashew butters

Every jar of Cleo Nut Butter Co cashew butter is ground and blended in small batches in Tennessee, with an ingredient list short enough to read out loud. Our cashews are conventionally grown, not organic, and come from Vietnam and Ivory Coast, depending on the lot. There are no emulsifiers and no added oils in any of our cashew butters.

  • Pure Cashew Butter: one ingredient, dry roasted cashews. Mellow, naturally creamy and gently sweet on its own.
  • Maple Vanilla Cashew Butter: dry roasted cashews, Vermont maple sugar and Madagascar ground vanilla bean powder. Soft, warm and just sweet enough.
  • Toasty Carob Cashew Butter: dry roasted cashews, organic Australian carob powder and date sugar. Toasty and mellow, and naturally caffeine-free because it is made with carob instead of cocoa.

Made to order: Most jars are made to order, and some popular flavors are made in batches. Please allow 7 to 10 business days for preparation before your order ships.

Shipping: We ship within Tennessee for now. Outside Tennessee? Join the nationwide shipping waitlist and we will email you when shipping opens in your state.

Allergens: Our cashew butters contain tree nuts (cashews). They are made in a kitchen that also handles peanuts and other tree nuts. Peanuts are kept on separate equipment from tree nuts. Please check the "Contains" line on each jar.

Cashew butter FAQ

Why is cashew butter more expensive than peanut butter?

Cashews cost more to grow, shell and ship. Each cashew apple carries a single nut, the shell holds a caustic oil that has to be dealt with before shelling, much of the shelling is done by hand, and most cashews travel to another country for processing. A pure cashew butter is mostly cashews by weight, so the price of the nut is most of the price of the jar.

What should the first ingredient be in cashew butter?

Cashews. Ingredients are listed by weight, so the first ingredient is most of the jar. If an oil, a sweetener or another nut comes first, the jar is mostly something else.

Does cashew butter need to be refrigerated?

Our cashew butters have no preservatives. Keep an unopened jar in a cool, dark place. After opening, refrigerate it and enjoy it while it is fresh.

Why is there oil on top of my cashew butter?

Our cashew butters have no added oils or emulsifiers, so the cashews' own oil can rise to the top. That is normal. Stir the whole jar until the oil is mixed back in.

Are your cashews organic?

No. Our cashews are conventionally grown, and they come from Vietnam and Ivory Coast, depending on the lot.

Is your cashew butter made in a peanut-free kitchen?

No. Our kitchen handles peanuts and tree nuts. Peanuts are kept on separate equipment from tree nuts, but please check the "Contains" line on each jar and decide what is right for you.

Shop small-batch cashew butter